Re: Relegation Decider : Mon Mar 07, 2022 9:52 pm  

Not saying butterworth couldnt do a good job and if he plays good luck to him and i hope he gets man of match but in context of the game because although its certainly not a relegation decieder its certainly a very big game and putting a kid in and a kid not in his preferred postion of what i believe could be bad to both him and the team toulouse will pepper him all night long.playing sl is a different level to under 19s some seem to forget.we saw it with poor murphy last week.so for me i think kaye may best option.glad im not willie though im justvhoping gaskell is fit

[PopTart]

Re: Relegation Decider : Mon Mar 07, 2022 9:58 pm  

Luppylad wrote:

Not saying butterworth couldnt do a good job and if he plays good luck to him and i hope he gets man of match but in context of the game because although its certainly not a relegation decieder its certainly a very big game and putting a kid in and a kid not in his preferred postion of what i believe could be bad to both him and the team toulouse will pepper him all night long.playing sl is a different level to under 19s some seem to forget.we saw it with poor murphy last week.so for me i think kaye may best option.glad im not willie though im justvhoping gaskell is fit

I don't see why Kay being out of position in a position he has never played is better than someone currently playing the position in the A team.
If he's not capable then fair enough but let's not hold him back just because he's young.
Murphy was different. He was in position surrounded by players out of position. That's a hard debut.
As you say, I'm glad it's not on me.

Re: Relegation Decider : Mon Mar 07, 2022 10:11 pm  

PopTart wrote:

I don't see why Kay being out of position in a position he has never played is better than someone currently playing the position in the A team.
If he's not capable then fair enough but let's not hold him back just because he's young.
Murphy was different. He was in position surrounded by players out of position. That's a hard debut.
As you say, I'm glad it's not on me.

Kay has played full back and stand off previously. And Crowther has played at hooker more than Kay. Just going by the friendlies, I wouldn’t say Butterworth is anywhere near ready yet.

Re: Relegation Decider : Mon Mar 07, 2022 10:35 pm  

PopTart wrote:

I don't see why Kay being out of position in a position he has never played is better than someone currently playing the position in the A team.
If he's not capable then fair enough but let's not hold him back just because he's young.
Murphy was different. He was in position surrounded by players out of position. That's a hard debut.
As you say, I'm glad it's not on me.

He played half back against hull kr last week robbie mann was fullback and jat hartley was often full back last season in under 19s.now im not putting the kid down and im all for giving kids ago when ready but is he ready esp out of his main postion i havent really seen him play so its not right for me to comment but for this id go for experience esp in such a hard postion

Re: Relegation Decider : Mon Mar 07, 2022 10:54 pm  

Luppylad wrote:

No half back robbie mann is playing full back

Any relation to Gerry Mann who played in the sixtys

Re: Relegation Decider : Mon Mar 07, 2022 11:27 pm  

alegend wrote:

Any relation to Gerry Mann who played in the sixtys

Or Manfred Mann who also played in the 60S ?

[PopTart]

Re: Relegation Decider : Mon Mar 07, 2022 11:53 pm  

Luppylad wrote:

He played half back against hull kr last week robbie mann was fullback and jat hartley was often full back last season in under 19s.now im not putting the kid down and im all for giving kids ago when ready but is he ready esp out of his main postion i havent really seen him play so its not right for me to comment but for this id go for experience esp in such a hard postion

Fair enough. I don't know enough to say whether he is ready.

Re: Relegation Decider : Tue Mar 08, 2022 6:21 am  

alegend wrote:

Any relation to Gerry Mann who played in the sixtys

No idea

Re: Relegation Decider : Tue Mar 08, 2022 8:02 am  

I know Gerry and as far as I am aware Robbie Mann is not a relative.

Re: Relegation Decider : Tue Mar 08, 2022 4:08 pm  

Super League

Wakefield Trinity v Toulouse Olympique XIII

11th March, KO: 19:30

Referee: T. Grant
Reserve Referee: N. Bennett
Touch Judge 1: A. Moore
Touch Judge 2: D. Bowmer
In Goal: S. Ellis
In Goal 2: A. Smith
Time Keeper: M. Hebblethwaite