[Chris71]

Re: Saints in the cup : Mon Jun 19, 2023 1:54 pm  

number 6 wrote:

Irregs#16 wrote:

Fash didn't move his body really. Percival had hold of him, and Taylor controlled the player going to ground. Fash cannot move his position.

exactly, worse case scenario was a fine, but even the panel could see he was in a position of no fault of his own, makes Wilkin and Peacock look a bit foolish too claiming it was a red all day!

Just shows that they both talk absolute poop, I said at the time you only have to look at Fash to see both his arms are trapped in between his body and Percivals, even Percival had hold of Fash so how any of those eejits on the BBC couldn't see that just shows they lack any credence and ability to be impartial.

Re: Saints in the cup : Mon Jun 19, 2023 2:58 pm  

Hasbag wrote:

Cator - No tripping motion was made.
So why did they get a penalty for it?
A lot of the time the MRP minutes show up how many decisions the refs really get wrong, bit rarely do they get dropped.

Think it’s a vicious cycle with refs. The more they face dissent and consequence, the harder recruitment and retention gets, and the standard drops even lower. We really are in a sorry state when Thaler is the best ref now.