I had Hull FC Tv last year and for the price I thought it was OK. I often watch games on a 42inch TV and its ok, a bit blurry when zoomed out but watchable. I suppose they have to encode it for streaming but the non sky games are about 1.2 gig which should give better picture quality but doesn't. Agree with Sky games, they are about 1.8gig but someone worse in quality.
They resolved some of the issues I asked for like an onscreen scoreboard and commentary although I agree about DDD, he is an embarrassment, slagging refs off all the time. I also asked for replays, I suppose this would require a lot more editing effort though but its a shame.
I will be getting it again this year still though, hopefully there will be more improvements.