I'd take him, Smith seemed to like him at Rovers. Can see him staying at Cas though

Terrible player

I would certainly take Whitley. I think he is quite underrated . He isn’t a marquee signing but I think he would be a very useful addition

Is it your ignorance or petty bias that makes you say that. Luis Johnson is an excellent player that unfortunately was injured most of last season. On return to fitness he was unfortunate that we had recruited well and he did not get the chance to impress.

He’s not exactly pulled up trees, been out on loan to various clubs and had injury issues. He’s not stood out at kr much either

I’d be disappointed if we signed him

Terrible is a bit harsh. I wouldn't have him as a starter, but as MR says would be a good depth signing. Unless Staveley /Armstrong etc are seen as ready for next season

On loan at Cas this season, that’s all after his injury problems last year. Before the injury he was playing well. It depends what you mean by pulling up trees. No he is not of international standard but then few are. If pulling up trees is your standard for signings FC will not be making many. He would be an improvement on both Fash and Cator so signing him would improve your squad.



My original post was to Smiggs who said he is a terrible player. He definitely is not and if that is his genuine assessment he understands little about the game.

Johnson didn’t pull up trees at kr., before that he was on loan to a few championship clubs.

We have already cator lane etc., we have enough squad fillers

We need beefing up in the forwards and he isn’t what we need.

We don't need squad fillers we need bona-fide starters. Our starting 17 is nowhere near good enough for this league. The players we currently have are mostly depth. Signing someone of his limited ability will not improve our situation, but just perpetuate it.

And resigning Fash and Cator will improve the situation? All they offer is energy and enthusiasm. Luis offers that plus rugby skills but you seem too blinkered to acknowledge that. Compared to Kane Linnett and James Batchelor yes he has limited ability and that’s the issue about him getting game time. Compared to Fash and Cator who are in your match day squad when available he’s a stand out.



Having said that it’s probably academic as I wouldn’t think he’d consider you anyway.

Cheeky Keith, he wouldn’t consider joining fc.

Don’t tell me he’s considering offers from wigan saints and host of Nrl clubs.

I do understand some kr fans are a bit giddy at the moment . Let’s see end of the season when fatigue and injuries are biting.

Will you be on fc forum in September?

No but he could well have better options. It depends I suppose on his relationship with Smith who signed him for Wire and Rovers. He obviously rates Luis which is more than some on here do.



I notice you didn’t question the rest of my post. Fash who wouldn’t even get in most SL squads received all those awards at the end of 2022. A journey man at best seen as the stand out player at your club. As most are still with you that must say something about the squad and they are still being resigned.

Not sure why anyone replies to any of your posts, you have shown your club colours. as nothing but a troll by creating multiple accounts.



I use to engage with you and although 90% of what you talked about biased rubbish, I bit like.this, you have lost all respect and m most people just ignore you.

Cator and Fash can play big minutes, make 40 plus tackles, Johnston is capable of that, doesn't have the engine.



I wouldn't be totally against him coming, as long as he isn't our main pack signings(expect that to be our quota players), would offer us size and an improvement on Lane.



On another note, watched Newcastle, thought Fitzgibbon had a good game think ge would be a good signing. Fritzell has excellent, no chance of him coming to SL yet, tipped for Origin

You have been blindsided by your your own prejudices. I have only one account but you believe what you want. There is no value in having more than one as I get enough bites as it is, your post above proves that.



Which actual part of my earlier post comes within the 90% rubbish? I’d be interested to know as it seems a pretty accurate assessment at the moment.

Of course Keith, that's why Billy disappeared, once people found out.



I'd give if I was you, no one is interested in your opinion.



You are finished on here.

Matt Whitley makes too much sense we should be all over it, question is will Smith be ruthless and sign him as well as a quota second row to add punch.

So why do you keep replying? Whose Billy?

Re Whitley IMo decent 2nd row but no stand out and certainly not a line breaker. He's a Stone lighter than Lane. Not exactly what where looking for

Are you trying to make some sort of point? You do pop up from time to time. You must have some sort of disability to believe the things you say. A bit like Trump if you keep repeating the same lie over and over again gullible people will start to believe it. I’m beginning to think some FC fans are like lots of the GOP supporters in the good old US of A.

I think the facts speak for themselves Billy.



This is like the Buddhist parable of the 2 arrows. The first arrow is that, for whatever reason, you made an embarrassing mistake, which has hurt you. The second arrow (you repeating the same reactive behaviours, pointless denials etc) is self inflicted and just prolonging your suffering. Only you can stop this by making peace and accepting the pain of arrow 1.

He did get caught out let’s be honest,,, but so have you on our secret forum more then once but you still keep coming back

You do talk garbage. You saying something does not make it true. It just makes you look foolish. You do not say what makes you believe something just post unrelated things that pop into your head.

Facts, what facts? Please do share.