Re: TV Games - Not Hull : Tue Aug 01, 2023 4:40 pm  

supersport wrote:

you loaned 3 players before your magic weekend cup final last year ,im sure it wouldnt have happened if the reserves were not playing the same day no big deal

It may be a cup final in your eyes.

Plus that was different as they were season long loans not just for one game.

Plus that was under our previous coaches, which myself and others critised for not playing enough young kids.

I'd be disappointed if Hull did the same.

Re: TV Games - Not Hull : Tue Aug 01, 2023 4:55 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

It may be a cup final in your eyes.

Plus that was different as they were season long loans not just for one game.

Plus that was under our previous coaches, which myself and others critised for not playing enough young kids.

I'd be disappointed if Hull did the same.

I’m sure FC will never do anything like that. TS or any subsequent coach will definitely not want to disappoint you Dave.

Re: TV Games - Not Hull : Tue Aug 01, 2023 5:09 pm  

No outrage over Leigh signing Oliver Gildart on a short term deal right before their big cup final?

[Chris71]

Re: TV Games - Not Hull : Tue Aug 01, 2023 5:12 pm  

Keiththered wrote:

Dave K. wrote:

It may be a cup final in your eyes.

Plus that was different as they were season long loans not just for one game.

Plus that was under our previous coaches, which myself and others critised for not playing enough young kids.

I'd be disappointed if Hull did the same.

I’m sure FC will never do anything like that. TS or any subsequent coach will definitely not want to disappoint you Dave.

As Dave has said they were long term loans which no one had or has issues with and that is totally different to 1 game loan deals. Also as Dave states a number of people were disappointed myself included we didn't play the young lads more, even Hodgson himself admitted that was a mistake.
As Hull FC supporter rugby league fan, if as a club we did short term loans for 1 game instead of using our reserves & academy players I'd be very disappointed in the club.

If teams start doing 1 week loan deals then what is the point of having squads as that's the whole purpose of a 1st team squad thats larger than the 17 that take to the field. This is just another example of why the reserve league should be enforced properly and all SL clubs should have suitable academies.

In all honesty its a bit of a smack in the face for the academy and reserve players at Rovers if they are over looked for one of the loan players and given the outrage when the club were denied an Elite licence you'd think that as a club you'd be able to cover 1 game with players from within the club.

Think this is another example of why the game is such a mess when there little or no incentive for clubs to promote their own players.

No one is against loans but the rules should be any loans has to be for a minimum 4 weeks.

Re: TV Games - Not Hull : Tue Aug 01, 2023 5:40 pm  

Ignore he Chris, he doesn't like the fact I've got him ignore, so can't see his pointless posts unless someone quotes him. Not sure he is on here, offers no debate (just digs), creates multiple profiles and hides when results don't go there way.

Feel for you Chris not been able to put him on ignore as a Mod.

Re: TV Games - Not Hull : Tue Aug 01, 2023 5:42 pm  

Steve0 wrote:

No outrage over Leigh signing Oliver Gildart on a short term deal right before their big cup final?

Don't understand why people can't see the difference.

Gildart is an international player signed to play 6 plus ganes against 3 reserve players signed for 1 game.

Re: TV Games - Not Hull : Tue Aug 01, 2023 5:56 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

No reasons will convince me that this isn't poor from Rovers, these loan players aren't experienced players.

I'd bet Rovers could rest 10 players and still put out a side made up of first team amd reserve players. If the reserve fixture needs to be postponed as a one off I don't think that's a big deal.

Ellis
Fishwick
Tennison
Barley
Gorman
PLT

All stepping up from reserves we probably could pull back Okoro and Moore from being on loan aswell

Then the academy lads will step up to reserves to fulfil the reserve fixture so let’s not go making out we aren’t using the academy players for this game

Re: TV Games - Not Hull : Tue Aug 01, 2023 5:58 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

Don't understand why people can't see the difference.

Gildart is an international player signed to play 6 plus ganes against 3 reserve players signed for 1 game.

Making a total mockery of Super League and the sport in general?

Authorities need to have a serious look at loans and the whole business of signing new players.

[Mild Rover]

Re: TV Games - Not Hull : Tue Aug 01, 2023 6:03 pm  

Chris71 wrote:

As Hull FC supporter rugby league fan, if as a club we did short term loans for 1 game instead of using our reserves & academy players I'd be very disappointed in the club.

I’m pretty sure it will be as well rather than instead of.

[Mild Rover]

Re: TV Games - Not Hull : Tue Aug 01, 2023 6:05 pm  

Steve0 wrote:

No outrage over Leigh signing Oliver Gildart on a short term deal right before their big cup final?

Once it became clear he can’t play in the CC final, not really. Even if he could, it’d have been his judgement I’d have questioned rather than Leigh’s.