Re: On to Saints : Mon Aug 08, 2022 3:15 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

If Mitch is back, then put Wynne on the wing and we are stronger.

Dont agree
Simm is much more rounded player than Wynne 10 kilos heavier and 3 inches taller and in fact slightly younger than Wynne
Also think Simm is faster than Wynne.
I agree Simm has made some handling errors with high balls but then again so has McIntosh
Lets see how he goes against us at the weekend .I think you may change your mind
Like to see him at centre

Re: On to Saints : Mon Aug 08, 2022 3:22 pm  

The young lad did his shoulder in the 6th minute and wasn't pulled until Faraimo brushed him off for 2 tries near the end.

[Chris71]

Re: On to Saints : Mon Aug 08, 2022 3:30 pm  

bonaire wrote:

Dont agree
Simm is much more rounded player than Wynne 10 kilos heavier and 3 inches taller and in fact slightly younger than Wynne
Also think Simm is faster than Wynne.
I agree Simm has made some handling errors with high balls but then again so has McIntosh
Lets see how he goes against us at the weekend .I think you may change your mind
Like to see him at centre

I would liked to have seen BH give Simm a run in his natural position of centre whilst with us rather than just play him on the wing as its a position he never looked totally comfortable. He'll have a stormer of a game on Sunday as well knowing our luck.

Re: On to Saints : Mon Aug 08, 2022 8:27 pm  

bonaire wrote:

Dont agree
Simm is much more rounded player than Wynne 10 kilos heavier and 3 inches taller and in fact slightly younger than Wynne
Also think Simm is faster than Wynne.
I agree Simm has made some handling errors with high balls but then again so has McIntosh
Lets see how he goes against us at the weekend .I think you may change your mind
Like to see him at centre

Not sure what this is based on, but from what I've seen on both Wynne and Simm play for Hull this season, Wynne is the much better player, Simm has too many mistakes and is poor is defence. His errors aren't just high balls either.

Re: On to Saints : Mon Aug 08, 2022 9:19 pm  

Does no one see Wynnes moments of madness, lashes out gets wound up, loses the ball thrashing out, the sin bins, sorry but until he matures he's a liability.

Dont get the people who chose to ignore it

Re: On to Saints : Mon Aug 08, 2022 9:54 pm  

Rocknrolla69er wrote:

Does no one see Wynnes moments of madness, lashes out gets wound up, loses the ball thrashing out, the sin bins, sorry but until he matures he's a liability.

Dont get the people who chose to ignore it

Its the same with McIntosh.Simm got all the criticism yet McIntosh makes plenty of errors with high balls and dropping the ball coming out of backfield.
Errors are part of the game but you have to have a balanced view

Re: On to Saints : Tue Aug 09, 2022 4:33 am  

Rocknrolla69er wrote:

Does no one see Wynnes moments of madness, lashes out gets wound up, loses the ball thrashing out, the sin bins, sorry but until he matures he's a liability.

Dont get the people who chose to ignore it

Apart from the Cas game, when else has he had moments of madness?

No one is ignoring it, but weighing up the strengths and weaknesses of both players on based on playing for Hull, Wynne is a much better player.

Re: On to Saints : Tue Aug 09, 2022 4:40 am  

bonaire wrote:

Its the same with McIntosh.Simm got all the criticism yet McIntosh makes plenty of errors with high balls and dropping the ball coming out of backfield.
Errors are part of the game but you have to have a balanced view

There is a big difference, one is signed in at Hull and one is on loan, do we want two wingers who make mistakes and are poor defenders?

I'm not convinced by Mcintosh, but he can finish and create things at time, not sure Simm has impressed enough in attack or defence.

We have Mcintosh, Wynne, Carlos, Scott, Mitch and Swift plus a few other young backs, so not sure Simm is needed.

Re: On to Saints : Tue Aug 09, 2022 6:01 am  

Dave K. wrote:

Apart from the Cas game, when else has he had moments of madness?

No one is ignoring it, but weighing up the strengths and weaknesses of both players on based on playing for Hull, Wynne is a much better player.

Saints at home
The Warrington game getting involved with matuatia

Numerous errors where he's thrashing about or lashing out as his heads gone after being tackled. Seen it all season from East stand. Needs to mature.

We talk about errors and discipline every week, but chose to ignore or not hold accountable the worst culprits......

Bad habit Hull fans have

Re: On to Saints : Tue Aug 09, 2022 7:43 am  

bonaire wrote:

Its the same with McIntosh.Simm got all the criticism yet McIntosh makes plenty of errors with high balls and dropping the ball coming out of backfield.

you have to have a balanced view

The irony of this remark brought a huge smile to my face.