Re: Childs : Thu Apr 07, 2011 1:57 pm  

airliebird58 wrote:

Quite agree with what you say, but respect has to work both ways. It could be argued that both Hull FC and Castleford where not shown respect/professionalism by the official in charge, or by the people who continue to put him in charge of top teer games when his record is there for all to see.

Thats also fair comment, he left the stadium showered, dressed and booted in under 20 mins, yet the arch enemy S Ganson always goes to both coaches afterwards to discuss individual issues and will admit if he is wrong...
there is the difference ..
I am sure childs will grow as his experience grows but in the meantime he has to use "ref sense" and even up penalty counts the old way and solve mistakes on the hoof as the other refs do ...
As RH said, he doesnt talk TO players he talks AT them...

Re: Childs : Thu Apr 07, 2011 1:58 pm  

Kosh wrote:

All the more reason to question why Noble wasn't charged after berating the officials at the Crusaders game last season in full view of an 11,000+ crowd at the KC.

very good point indeed!

Re: Childs : Thu Apr 07, 2011 2:09 pm  

ICECREAMMAN wrote:

Thats also fair comment, he left the stadium showered, dressed and booted in under 20 mins, yet the arch enemy S Ganson always goes to both coaches afterwards to discuss individual issues and will admit if he is wrong...
there is the difference ..
I am sure childs will grow as his experience grows but in the meantime he has to use "ref sense" and even up penalty counts the old way and solve mistakes on the hoof as the other refs do ...
As RH said, he doesnt talk TO players he talks AT them...

Lets hope he does grow in experience as we all know how short of officials the game is.
In the meantime though Richard Agar has been put on a charge, whilst Mr Child will be busy refereeing the Superleague Champs on Friday, according to the RFL website.
See what I mean about respect working both ways?

Re: Childs : Thu Apr 07, 2011 2:15 pm  

airliebird58 wrote:

Lets hope he does grow in experience as we all know how short of officials the game is.
In the meantime though Richard Agar has been put on a charge, whilst Mr Child will be busy refereeing the Superleague Champs on Friday, according to the RFL website.
See what I mean about respect working both ways?

wait for the details, if they ever come out.

Re: Childs : Thu Apr 07, 2011 2:28 pm  

Standee wrote:

wait for the details, if they ever come out.

What details he left within 20 minutes without going and discussing points with the coaches ....Now I wonder why

I doubt very much the full extent of what happened will be made public.

Re: Childs : Thu Apr 07, 2011 2:31 pm  

berrigans bitch wrote:

What details he left within 20 minutes without going and discussing points with the coaches ....Now I wonder why

I doubt very much the full extent of what happened will be made public.

Re: Childs : Thu Apr 07, 2011 2:35 pm  

berrigans bitch wrote:

What details he left within 20 minutes without going and discussing points with the coaches ....Now I wonder why

I doubt very much the full extent of what happened will be made public.

I agree, the edge of the carpet will remian bumpy for a while.

Re: Childs : Thu Apr 07, 2011 2:51 pm  

Standee wrote:

wait for the details, if they ever come out.

It does seem that something was said behind the scenes, but I wasn't there, so can't comment. What I did see last Friday was a terrible refereeing display from Mr Child who'll just go on his merry way to ref at Wigan tomorrow. Best of luck to both them and Le Cats, they'll need it if he keeps on form!

Re: Childs : Thu Apr 07, 2011 3:12 pm  

Now you feel like we did about Thaler. Childs though makes Thaler look class, he took our freindly against Salford and chucked over 30pens out, most for holding down. Vella did go to him a few times and you could imagine him saying 'Come on mate both sides are fecked as its our second hitout, can we shelve this holding down crap and just play?'
He then sin binned 2 and sent off 1 for Salford (they may have voiced opinions). Mcrae did however be more diplomatic than Agar!

ps I would like to see the odds for less then 10 pens tomorrow! might be worth a few bob.

Re: Childs : Thu Apr 07, 2011 7:55 pm  

blakeysrobin wrote:

Now you feel like we did about Thaler. Childs though makes Thaler look class, he took our freindly against Salford and chucked over 30pens out, most for holding down. Vella did go to him a few times and you could imagine him saying 'Come on mate both sides are fecked as its our second hitout, can we shelve this holding down crap and just play?'
He then sin binned 2 and sent off 1 for Salford (they may have voiced opinions). Mcrae did however be more diplomatic than Agar!

ps I would like to see the odds for less then 10 pens tomorrow! might be worth a few bob.

Would Mcrae have been so diplomatic if he had just witnessed his side been fisted for 80mins and drop 2 super league points in the process?