Re: Almost half way there-season tickets : Fri Oct 30, 2015 12:29 pm  

IMO he simply had more cash offered at salford

Re: Almost half way there-season tickets : Fri Oct 30, 2015 12:33 pm  

Potential bullet dodged if you ask me

Re: Almost half way there-season tickets : Fri Oct 30, 2015 12:59 pm  

Hull White Star wrote:

I bumped into Jamie Shaul out and about on Tuesday afternoon - I asked him about Carney and he said exactly that it was down to Jordan Thompson and how comfortable he was about it. That was straight from his mouth, I can only tell you what he told me, now he may be lying to cover the fact that Carney just got a better offer from Salford and chose them, but I seriously doubt that.

Jordan would have left IMO if Carney came through family loyalty. This probably sat uncomfortably with some of the other players. It would have done with me. Then imagine something happens, things like this get dragged up and all of a sudden you have a dressing room in disharmony.
If this is actually what happened, I can personally do nothing but applaud the club for being open and honest with the players and asking their opinion

Re: Almost half way there-season tickets : Fri Oct 30, 2015 1:12 pm  

hull smallears wrote:

Jordan would have left IMO if Carney came through family loyalty. This probably sat uncomfortably with some of the other players. It would have done with me. Then imagine something happens, things like this get dragged up and all of a sudden you have a dressing room in disharmony.
If this is actually what happened, I can personally do nothing but applaud the club for being open and honest with the players and asking their opinion

Agree. Whilst is disappointing a player of Carney's calibre won't be joining us, if this is the process the club took I'm in full backing of it.

We had a similar situation at my amateur club where the coaches asked us whether we'd be happy with a player joining us. 99% of the time a new player would just turn up training and be welcomed into the fold with no questions asked, but the player in question we knew of, he played for us a few years earlier, left under a cloud and pi$$ed a lot of people off.

Before anyone says it, yes, there's a huge difference between professional and amateur sport, but I think the point still stands regarding keeping team spirit and morale. In a sport like rugby league where your putting your bodies on the line for each other, where communication across the line is vital, your living in each others pockets etc, a rift in the team can be catastrophic.

Re: Almost half way there-season tickets : Fri Oct 30, 2015 2:03 pm  

Faithful One wrote:

A bit torn with this one. Carney would have been a great signing, and one which would have completed our squad. But, is it really worth the risk of causing any sort of rift in the camp in such a big year for the club? Whether its one player or ten, people would start to take sides.

Spot on for me. I've posted something similar on another thread before I read this one.

Re: Almost half way there-season tickets : Fri Oct 30, 2015 2:15 pm  

hull smallears wrote:

Jordan would have left IMO if Carney came through family loyalty. This probably sat uncomfortably with some of the other players. It would have done with me. Then imagine something happens, things like this get dragged up and all of a sudden you have a dressing room in disharmony.
If this is actually what happened, I can personally do nothing but applaud the club for being open and honest with the players and asking their opinion

Exactly. If this is what has happened then I think the club has handled this very well. I know some people were saying when the rumours were floating around about the vote that it was a joke we was doing it but I think it's been the right call as it's a somewhat unique situation and it involves one of our players.

Re: Almost half way there-season tickets : Fri Oct 30, 2015 2:44 pm  

ccs wrote:

That telephone thingy looks a bit complicated as well - I wonder why I could buy FC Live over the 'phone but bumpy can't?

I phoned up a while back and was told that I couldn't sign up for the membership and get the FC Live discount over the phone. I've being into store today whilst I'm up and sorted it though there was another issue that I didn't want to kick up a fuss whilst there and have contacted the club directly.
It'd be so much easier to do the whole lot online just ticking a check box for what you want to purchase and pay directly then collect the pack whenever.

Re: Almost half way there-season tickets : Fri Oct 30, 2015 5:39 pm  

Over 500 passes sold today alone according to someone in the shop?

Re: Almost half way there-season tickets : Fri Oct 30, 2015 5:58 pm  

You have to give pearson credit,spread a bit of bird seed about regarding carney and the pigeons bite.

Re: Almost half way there-season tickets : Fri Oct 30, 2015 6:02 pm  

YAWN,