Re: In's and out's : Sat Oct 06, 2018 5:40 pm  

Our pack is weak . Without some significant improvement expect a tough 2019.

Re: In's and out's : Sat Oct 06, 2018 6:14 pm  

if we can get a fit pack on the field I don't think it is, Taylor, Green,Bowden, Masi, Bienik,paea, Back three manu mini, Hadley westy, plus the 2 lads weve signed who could be anything, throw in lane and fash, maybe griffin, it looks ok to me,

Re: In's and out's : Sat Oct 06, 2018 6:25 pm  

hull2524 wrote:

if we can get a fit pack on the field I don't think it is, Taylor, Green,Bowden, Masi, Bienik,paea, Back three manu mini, Hadley westy, plus the 2 lads weve signed who could be anything, throw in lane and fash, maybe griffin, it looks ok to me,

Mani and Mini are past it . 2 years ago, yes , next year , no .

Re: In's and out's : Sat Oct 06, 2018 6:26 pm  

HFC Boy wrote:

Our pack is weak . Without some significant improvement expect a tough 2019.

I agree
I think the club have made a huge mistake not refreshing the forwards with Super League quality players.
A starting front row of Taylor,Bowden,Paea and Green If all are fit will hardly be a frightening prospect for our opponents.
Add an ageing injury prone second row and we will struggle to make the top eight never mind the top five.
A miscalculation by the coach to go with the same squad and possibly being too loyal to some players has left the club realising too late that it was the wrong decision and leaving very few options to strengthen.

Re: In's and out's : Sun Oct 07, 2018 8:33 pm  

Well...

Matthew Shaw
‏ @M_Shaw1

Hull FC. The Black and Whites are plotting a return for back-rower Jordan Thompson, while Matty Dawson-Jones is set to join the club from Leigh.

Re: In's and out's : Sun Oct 07, 2018 9:40 pm  

Fook me, are we preparing for the championship? matty dawson and jordan thompson? Back to the agar years recruitment wise

Re: In's and out's : Sun Oct 07, 2018 10:05 pm  

If we’re signing people like Dawson to bolster a reserve team, we may as well have kept Rawsthorne.
Ditto Turgut for Thompson.

Re: In's and out's : Sun Oct 07, 2018 11:12 pm  

Backwards step, Thompson isn't any better than some of the forwards who would be cheaper we have released. Dawson is a poor version of the wingers we have. Looks to me that we will have a strong reserve side, a bit worried about the first 17, can't see challenging again next year. Pearson can't come out with statements like he has and then sign these type of players, it's not fair on the fans.

Re: In's and out's : Mon Oct 08, 2018 12:11 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

Backwards step, Thompson isn't any better than some of the forwards who would be cheaper we have released. Dawson is a poor version of the wingers we have. Looks to me that we will have a strong reserve side, a bit worried about the first 17, can't see challenging again next year. Pearson can't come out with statements like he has and then sign these type of players, it's not fair on the fans.

How does it work salary cap wise if you have a reserve side

Re: In's and out's : Mon Oct 08, 2018 12:19 pm  

fun time frankie wrote:

How does it work salary cap wise if you have a reserve side

It makes no difference, top 25 count on the cap.