Re: Next up Catalan : Tue May 18, 2021 11:48 am  

Rocknrolla69er wrote:

Everyone says it every week , no consistncys from the officials.

What did everyone make of the obstruction just before the try they scored the one where the kick hit the post then Langi scored

Looked clear as day with the Catalans ball carrier running into the back of his teammate who was in the defensive line, did I see it wrong? I couldn't believe it wasn't given

Yeah it was Garcia, he didn't surrender himself just started running back the way he came. Clear penalty.

Re: Next up Catalan : Tue May 18, 2021 12:10 pm  

How are sneyd and Reynolds going to get a partnership going if after 1 average game you drop one. Madness. Need to get faraimo in the 17 plus Brown. We are struggling for size on the bench

[Chris71]

Re: Next up Catalan : Tue May 18, 2021 12:15 pm  

The Hollywood Frasier wrote:

Yeah it was Garcia, he didn't surrender himself just started running back the way he came. Clear penalty.

Also Kasiano was about 1ft in front of play when the ball was kicked so was offside. It was right inline of where I was sat.

Re: Next up Catalan : Tue May 18, 2021 12:17 pm  

Was it the Tom Davies try as well, from the crossfield kick, where the chasers were all offside - as it was from the 2nd kick that they scored?

Have watched bits of the game back, and even the decision to penalise Fonua for the challenge on Tomkins was harsh. Tomkins changes his positioning to see Fonua off

Re: Next up Catalan : Tue May 18, 2021 12:29 pm  

I can't login to ourleague anymore to watch the replay, it thinks I'm half way thru' applying, but none of the drop down menus work.

Is it just me?

edit: Working ok again now.

Re: Next up Catalan : Tue May 18, 2021 1:51 pm  

Satae: "Opponent is dropping to ground. There is no swinging arm. Sin bin sufficient"

Re: Next up Catalan : Tue May 18, 2021 2:02 pm  

ccs wrote:

Satae: "Opponent is dropping to ground. There is no swinging arm. Sin bin sufficient"

Small mercies I suppose.

Re: Next up Catalan : Tue May 18, 2021 2:10 pm  

scarrie wrote:

I didn't get a particularly good view of the incident from the West Upper so can anyone give their thoughts on Satae's sin bin?
From my distant vantage point it looked like the Catalans player slipped as Satae was going into tackle him and 10 mins seemed harsh.
If he cops a ban then we are in a world of trouble in the front row next week.

dont worry we have johnstone and Scott

Re: Next up Catalan : Tue May 18, 2021 2:15 pm  

scarrie wrote:

We do seem to getting a sin-bin almost every game at the moment. Some deserved and some ridiculous.

Our discipline since the early rounds has been very poor and i have said several times the coach has to step in here otherwise we are simply giving a result to the opposition and wearing the team out having to do so much defending

[Chris71]

Re: Next up Catalan : Tue May 18, 2021 2:52 pm  

scarrie wrote:

ccs wrote:

Satae: "Opponent is dropping to ground. There is no swinging arm. Sin bin sufficient"

Small mercies I suppose.

Agree it is small mercies but much like Brown who was sin binned wrongly (when compared to the same tackle by Powell on Griffin in the same game earlier in the half which didn't even get penalised) Satae was sin binned for Maloney losing his footing and colliding with Satae, which never warranted a penalty let alone, never mind Kendal brandishing a yellow card. How it could have been deemed a high tackle in the first place when Maloney was knee height due to purely losing his footing is a new one on me.

Whilst our discipline hasn't been great those are two incidents that have resulted in us wrongly being down to 12 men (or persons/beings) for 10 mins.

These are questions that should be getting asked of the Officials as there appears to be no accountability for their mistakes, which we know happen but the concerning issue is the amount of mistakes and inconsistencies not just game by game but half by half of the same game.