Re: Three scores up and... : Mon Feb 25, 2019 11:04 pm  

His Bobness wrote:

The still pictures do prove pretty conclusively that it was a try I think if it had been on SKY with all the technology it would have been given.

It wasn't and Salford were good value overall.

The still picture I have seen certainly suggests it was a try, but it can hardly be classed as conclusive. You don't know if he has already bounced it before his hands ended up on it. Did he try to catch and then ground it or did he just put his hands straight on the bouncing ball?

Re: Three scores up and... : Mon Feb 25, 2019 11:08 pm  

fun time frankie wrote:

When’s the open top bus parade

We typically reserve that for after we win at wembley. Unlike your lot that have one for a 50-0 drubbing.

Re: Three scores up and... : Tue Feb 26, 2019 12:21 pm  

A Adler wrote:

We typically reserve that for after we win at wembley. Unlike your lot that have one for a 50-0 drubbing.

Where have you been for the last six months

Re: Three scores up and... : Tue Feb 26, 2019 12:55 pm  

The still photo of Tomkins scoring is inconclusive. Did he knock on and then touch it down or squirt out after touching it down?

The reason we lost is lack of creativity which is criminal this season with our two halfbacks behind some pretty big forwards.

I will point out the obvious reasons we lost....

Hall running out of the line for his missed intercept.

Every time Tommy Lee was on the field we lost momentum in attack and weaker in defence. Drop Lee and play Lawler and Atkin at Hooker, they both offer a lot more than slow, predictable Lee (who also threw that stupid long pass that went to ground).

Re: Three scores up and... : Tue Feb 26, 2019 11:08 pm  

Gallanteer wrote:

The still photo of Tomkins scoring is inconclusive. Did he knock on and then touch it down or squirt out after touching it down?

The reason we lost is lack of creativity which is criminal this season with our two halfbacks behind some pretty big forwards.

I will point out the obvious reasons we lost....

Hall running out of the line for his missed intercept.

Every time Tommy Lee was on the field we lost momentum in attack and weaker in defence. Drop Lee and play Lawler and Atkin at Hooker, they both offer a lot more than slow, predictable Lee (who also threw that stupid long pass that went to ground).

The pass on that attempted interception by Hall was so far forward as two other trys was in the second half, not that it counts for out now...

Re: Three scores up and... : Wed Feb 27, 2019 12:42 am  

fun time frankie wrote:

Where have you been for the last six months

Internet been acting up. Just got it fixed last weekend.

Re: Three scores up and... : Wed Feb 27, 2019 7:29 am  

A Adler wrote:

Internet been acting up. Just got it fixed last weekend.

Coincidence you not got a phone then with internet if Hardaker had of kicked the conversion would your internet still have been playing up I think it might

Re: Three scores up and... : Thu Feb 28, 2019 12:17 am  

fun time frankie wrote:

Coincidence you not got a phone then with internet if Hardaker had of kicked the conversion would your internet still have been playing up I think it might

Is that one question or two? Hard to tell if you don't put one of these on the end '?'

Re: Three scores up and... : Thu Feb 28, 2019 9:30 am  

A Adler wrote:

Is that one question or two? Hard to tell if you don't put one of these on the end '?'

Answer either or deflect your choice