10 of the best : Fri Nov 11, 2016 10:33 pm  

Seeing as its off season ...!!!

What would be the best 17 you've had in the last 10 years ? , so starting from the 2006 season and try and put players in the positions they mostly played

[Mild Rover]

Re: 10 of the best : Fri Nov 11, 2016 10:50 pm  

Ah, some lovely SL nostalgia. IMO and off the top of my head...

Briscoe, Fox, Jake Webster, Welham (partly for length of service, partly for the pinball try and partly to annoy SirStan), Sio (honourable mention for Disco Hodgson).

I'll come back to stand-off, Dobson

Vella, J.Hodgson, Paea, Newton, Galea, Murrell (maybe a bit sentimental, but only a bit)

Fisher, Gene, Geez we've been through some props - Weyman, even though he only did one season. And Aizue. Again, some sentiment.

Clear bias towards our early years in SL. there's 11 overseas players in there already, I think, so I'll give the nod to Cooke over Blake Green at stand-off.

Might do a disappointing 17 later on. Short odds on the inclusion of Wayne Ulugia and Ryan Bailey.

Re: 10 of the best : Sat Nov 12, 2016 7:40 am  

Mild Rover wrote:

Might do a disappointing 17 later on. Short odds on the inclusion of Wayne Ulugia and Ryan Bailey.

Would Willie Mason make for selection?

Jeez, both Hull and Rovers have made some pretty ordinary signings during the SL era, even when not in the "premier elite".

Would be interesting to have both sets of fans compile their "Most disappointing signings since 1996 XIII" and work out which team would triumph, although I think the idea would probably be to celebrate which team was the worst.

[Mild Rover]

Re: 10 of the best : Sat Nov 12, 2016 10:31 am  

old frightful wrote:

Would Willie Mason make for selection?

Jeez, both Hull and Rovers have made some pretty ordinary signings during the SL era, even when not in the "premier elite".

Would be interesting to have both sets of fans compile their "Most disappointing signings since 1996 XIII" and work out which team would triumph, although I think the idea would probably be to celebrate which team was the worst.

Aye, Mason would be one of the first names on that team sheet too. Also, Sean Gleeson.

The thing is then, there'd be players who I'd feel bad about using to fill out the squad. Campese and Justin Poore didn't get injured deliberately. Kris Keating's form was indifferent, but I always had the impression he was trying. And in fairness to somebody like Bailey even, if he had genuine issues to work through, that's not something he'll have done deliberately either.

Re: 10 of the best : Sat Nov 12, 2016 10:44 am  

Clinton mills Mika crossman bailey Mason fozard Gannon were all gash in different ways. Byron Ford was good to watch and steel. Always rated morrison above Netherton but like donno he just wasn't big enough but massive heart

Re: 10 of the best : Sat Nov 12, 2016 11:02 am  

craig hkr wrote:

Clinton mills Mika crossman bailey Mason fozard Gannon were all gash in different ways. Byron Ford was good to watch and steel. Always rated morrison above Netherton but like donno he just wasn't big enough but massive heart

I wouldn't put Fozzard in the worst signings personally

Re: 10 of the best : Sat Nov 12, 2016 12:18 pm  

Misili Man's got to get in that team, and who was that lad we flew over from Australia last year, he played a game got trashed so we sacked him?

Just looking through some old squads there's people who I have no idea who they were.

Ryan O'Hara? Did he have a beard?

That big pudding Mills, Danny Ward, Andreus Bauer ffs!

Re: 10 of the best : Sat Nov 12, 2016 12:41 pm  

I had a gallenteer /tilse style hatred of Gareth morton back in the day.all my pals loved him but he certainly didn't play to his size attack or defence.stanley and fisher were the opposite same for cockayne for all the side issues.Vella stands out with Newton and Galea. .Goddard was a good centre certainly as good as any in last few year

Re: 10 of the best : Sat Nov 12, 2016 2:57 pm  

Best Team:

Briscoe
Sio
Goddard
J Webster
D Hodgson
Cooke
Dobson
Vella
J Hodgson
Weyman
Newton
Galea
Puletua

Worst Team:

Eden
Ratu
Bauer
Ulugia
George
Keating
I'Anson
Mason
Carlile
Bailey
O'Hara
E Tuimavave
Langley

Re: 10 of the best : Sat Nov 12, 2016 3:29 pm  

Pickering Red wrote:

Best Team:

Briscoe
Sio
Goddard
J Webster
D Hodgson
Cooke
Dobson
Vella
J Hodgson
Weyman
Newton
Galea
Puletua

Worst Team:

Eden
Fitzhenry
Bauer
Ulugia
George
Keating
I'Anson
Mason
Carlile
Bailey
O'Hara
E Tuimavave
Langley

Fitzhenry? Really?

Just focussing on wingers you could have listed Omari Caro, Sam Latus or Liam Colbon, all way behind Fitz, and that's before he re-invented himself as interchange hooker with the Fish.