: Thu Dec 04, 2008 5:32 pm  

dholli12 wrote:

Caliban does the ban on blades just cover metal ones or are the plastic moulded ones also banned?

Thats a question alot of people (inc. me) are asking.
If it does cover plastic moulded blades - then im £100 out of pocket.

: Thu Dec 04, 2008 6:52 pm  

dholli12 wrote:

Yeah superfast i agree about ref, not the best but as you said consistent. look forward to playing you again!
Caliban does the ban on blades just cover metal ones or are the plastic moulded ones also banned?

I would say blades are blades, be it metal tipped or not.

: Thu Dec 04, 2008 8:05 pm  

Normy Knight wrote:

I would say blades are blades, be it metal tipped or not.

But define blades?
Because if your are referring to the 'blades' as on the modern nike vapors (like below) then they arent harmful atall!

Whereas there are the genuine rugby blades that are quite leathel that are still openly available.

: Fri Dec 05, 2008 1:37 am  

super-fast-winger wrote:

But define blades?
Because if your are referring to the 'blades' as on the modern nike vapors (like below) then they arent harmful atall!

Whereas there are the genuine rugby blades that are quite leathel that are still openly available.

I don't know the make up or compound of those blades so its hard to comment.

I'm geussing here, when your walking on concrete or tarmac with your boots on, can you still scuff the edges of the blades, can it sharpen them?

I've seen refs check boots and you have, some do a good job and some don't.

I don't think ban is really aimed at youth and open age but BARLA will encompass all though.

I think it is mainly aimed at the young ones, how many times have you seen junior players walking up the street in their boots going to training, I bet its loads, I know I have.

BTW the RFL have not imposed a ban on blades, but I think that is more to do with worrying if some boot company sues them.

: Fri Dec 05, 2008 9:17 am  

Normy Knight wrote:

I don't know the make up or compound of those blades so its hard to comment.

I'm geussing here, when your walking on concrete or tarmac with your boots on, can you still scuff the edges of the blades, can it sharpen them?

I've seen refs check boots and you have, some do a good job and some don't.

I don't think ban is really aimed at youth and open age but BARLA will encompass all though.

I think it is mainly aimed at the young ones, how many times have you seen junior players walking up the street in their boots going to training, I bet its loads, I know I have.

BTW the RFL have not imposed a ban on blades, but I think that is more to do with worrying if some boot company sues them.

Maybe so, I was under the impression that the ban on blades referred to those that are similar to just a strip of metal. - That have been banned in both professional and amateur football for years.

If the ban does refer to the style pictured above then its a somewhat stupid decision as I would say over 50% of players wear a similar style due to the grip, and also they can be used all year round.
Problem is that BARLA havent quite claryfied what they mean.

: Fri Dec 05, 2008 10:04 am  

super-fast-winger wrote:

Maybe so, I was under the impression that the ban on blades referred to those that are similar to just a strip of metal. - That have been banned in both professional and amateur football for years.

If the ban does refer to the style pictured above then its a somewhat stupid decision as I would say over 50% of players wear a similar style due to the grip, and also they can be used all year round.
Problem is that BARLA havent quite claryfied what they mean.

Apparently the statement regarding the ban has been removed from Barla website, awaiting legal advice, decision to be made in january.
regarding all blades metal tipped and moulded.

: Fri Dec 05, 2008 10:43 am  

super-fast-winger wrote:

Problem is that BARLA havent quite claryfied what they mean.

Another ill thought out decision from BARLA. This blades issue has been ongoing for ages. If you're going to ban them do so from the start of next season.

I've just forked out £100 for some new boots a few months ago and whilst I could afford to replace them there will be plenty who can't.

: Fri Dec 05, 2008 12:12 pm  

Anybody know if Rugby Union still use them? (Blades)

: Fri Dec 05, 2008 12:25 pm  

Normy Knight wrote:

Anybody know if Rugby Union still use them? (Blades)

Blades aren't banned in Union. Boots are checked by the ref before the game and any boots which are deemed dangerous (blades or studs) are not allowed.

: Fri Dec 05, 2008 12:46 pm  

Caliban wrote:

Blades aren't banned in Union. Boots are checked by the ref before the game and any boots which are deemed dangerous (blades or studs) are not allowed.

Same as us then.

If Football which it has, RL and Union all decide to ban them maybe the makers will do something about it.