Re: Off contract : Wed Oct 24, 2018 4:56 pm  

not bothered about dickinson leaving was never going to be a regular prop for us bit like nathan mason it wont come back to haunt us... and johnson too who we let go.

matty english impressed more than those.

wakefield have just signed ben reynolds a half back so cant see brough going there, sound usual rubbish about brough we get at least three times a year

Re: Off contract : Wed Oct 24, 2018 5:58 pm  

Syned and Chisholm offered to giants, Chisholm rejected not sure on syned, the brough to wakey gathering momentum

Re: Off contract : Wed Oct 24, 2018 7:22 pm  

Who do you mean by Syned? Is this Sneyd spelt badly or someone else? If Sneyd, do you mean Marc Sneyd? i would find that unlikely

Re: Off contract : Wed Oct 24, 2018 7:24 pm  

Sorry grammar police, yes mark syned from hull they offered him poor deal so agent shopping him around

Re: Off contract : Wed Oct 24, 2018 7:35 pm  

Apologies, no offence meant, just wanted clarification on the player. Marc Sneyd would be a very good signing for us to replace Broughy and doesn't even take an overseas spot, would be absolutely for that

Re: Off contract : Wed Oct 24, 2018 7:54 pm  

One year left on hull deal and offered less so been shopped around and giants been asked, no answer back as yet

Re: Off contract : Thu Oct 25, 2018 2:22 pm  

Club is an absolute shambles really. They must have known Stone was on his way out, yet let him re sign/sign players.

If there is a big issue with the Uate deal then just pull it in my eyes. Its not the position we exactly need to strengthen the most is it?

Not surprised Dickinson has gone but we do need to try get rid of Adam Walne and Jordan Rankin as well.

Id be happy to let Brough go if we brought in Marc Sneyd. If Seb is going we should also be looking to bring in Kyle Amor who is available from St Helens. Infact, we would be better trying to offload Walne and Roche and bring in Amor and keep Seb.

I don't buy into that we are full to cap as we were going to re sign Hinchy and possibly Mamo.

As it stands with the squad we have currently got, we wont be anywhere near relegation but we wont make the play offs. Other clubs are really strengthening such as Catalans, Leeds, Wigan, St Helens, Salford far more than us.

Re: Off contract : Thu Oct 25, 2018 2:48 pm  

GiantJake1988 wrote:

Club is an absolute shambles really. They must have known Stone was on his way out, yet let him re sign/sign players.

If there is a big issue with the Uate deal then just pull it in my eyes. Its not the position we exactly need to strengthen the most is it?

Not surprised Dickinson has gone but we do need to try get rid of Adam Walne and Jordan Rankin as well.

Id be happy to let Brough go if we brought in Marc Sneyd. If Seb is going we should also be looking to bring in Kyle Amor who is available from St Helens. Infact, we would be better trying to offload Walne and Roche and bring in Amor and keep Seb.

I don't buy into that we are full to cap as we were going to re sign Hinchy and possibly Mamo.

As it stands with the squad we have currently got, we wont be anywhere near relegation but we wont make the play offs. Other clubs are really strengthening such as Catalans, Leeds, Wigan, St Helens, Salford far more than us.

Why don't you actually wait until recruitment has finished before you make assumptions on the strength of the squad. Any player leaving is clearly going as the current coach believes he has better options available.
your post might have some validity if you had actually done any research.
Wigan have lost Tomkins, Bateman and Sutton
Leeds have lost Moon, Hall and Delaney plus probably a few more. They have brought in a couple of players.
Salford have lost Burgess,Tasi,Hauraki and Kopczak.
St Helens have lost Barba and Wilkin and brought 2 in.

How is any of that called strengthening.

And Kyle Amor is well past his best and would not offer an improvement and our current squad.

Re: Off contract : Thu Oct 25, 2018 4:50 pm  

things arent just quiet at the giants, other clubs too

we didnt do too bad once we got our players back from injury and got woolford in so maybe wholesale changes arent needed, just fitness!

id have sneyd, great kicker and i love those in a team worth their weight in gold

amor too is a good prop if we fancied him

maybe ronan micheal can step up and follow in matty english's steps

Re: Off contract : Thu Oct 25, 2018 7:57 pm  

Well said Stella Kid