Re: Salary Cap Value for Money : Mon May 27, 2019 6:15 am  

jonh wrote:

Agree Bullock and Flower should be Props 3 & 4.

2 quality Props needed, Clarke signed up, so looking like we need 1 real top class Prop.

I’d be tempted to play Flower at 13 as an extra prop making Clarke our 3rd choice, Bullock 4th but we’d still need 2 quality props.

[Fantastic Mr Catpiss]

Re: Salary Cap Value for Money : Mon May 27, 2019 7:20 am  

post wrote:

Sorry. Tom Lineham is garbage and like most other players from Hull, can’t play when they leave Hull.

Toby King is garbage, the worst Warrington centre I’ve ever known.

Dec Patton is bang average.

Mike Cooper is a shadow of the player who played in the NRL.

Currie is injury prone and since his last injury hasn’t done anything of note.

Etc, Austin is a cracking player as is Mamo, Charnely, Goodwin, Hill, Clarke, etc.

All in all those average players are coached by a decent coach, and even yesterday they played terrible and still beat us.

I know you've had a bad weekend, and you're hitting out hun,but thats a load of crap(cept maybe the patton bit)

Re: Salary Cap Value for Money : Mon May 27, 2019 7:46 am  

Fantastic Mr Catpiss wrote:

I know you've had a bad weekend, and you're hitting out hun,but thats a load of crap(cept maybe the patton bit)

I wondered how long it would take to get a bite.

Re: Salary Cap Value for Money : Mon May 27, 2019 8:50 am  

WARRIOR5 wrote:

I was highlighting the players you slated in your list hence why I didn’t mention Tomkins, Bateman and Sutton. And I’d say all three were replaced with Hardaker, Greenwood and Bullock but I can’t be bothered with that debate again.

Hardly like for like though. Hardaker been out the game 18 months and has issues.
Greenwood potential, but not a patch on Bateman
Bullock replacing Sutton - like replacing fine dining with a greasy kebab.

All three have been replaced by much lesser quality, yet we are told our cap is full - how can that be unless we are overpaying?

Re: Salary Cap Value for Money : Mon Jun 03, 2019 4:06 am  

post wrote:

Sorry. Tom Lineham is garbage and like most other players from Hull, can’t play when they leave Hull.

Toby King is garbage, the worst Warrington centre I’ve ever known.

Dec Patton is bang average.

Mike Cooper is a shadow of the player who played in the NRL.

Currie is injury prone and since his last injury hasn’t done anything of note.

Etc, Austin is a cracking player as is Mamo, Charnely, Goodwin, Hill, Clarke, etc.

All in all those average players are coached by a decent coach, and even yesterday they played terrible and still beat us.

'Tom Lineham garbage'!....I stopped reading your post there.

He simply IS the best winger in SL after maybe Makinson but just.
Charnely isn't as complete a player as Lineham and thrives off a good centre and always did...he's as good as the Charnely that left Wigan...I'll agree that Wire 3/4s aren't the best passers.
Take off the cherry specs.

Re: Salary Cap Value for Money : Mon Jun 03, 2019 7:17 am  

rubber duckie wrote:

'Tom Lineham garbage'!....I stopped reading your post there.

He simply IS the best winger in SL after maybe Makinson but just.
Charnely isn't as complete a player as Lineham and thrives off a good centre and always did...he's as good as the Charnely that left Wigan...I'll agree that Wire 3/4s aren't the best passers.
Take off the cherry specs.

comedy gold

Re: Salary Cap Value for Money : Mon Jun 03, 2019 8:52 am  

If Tom Lineham is in the best two wingers in Superleague then it's no wonder the game is in the mess it is.

Re: Salary Cap Value for Money : Mon Jun 03, 2019 8:58 am  

Wingers better than Lineham:

Makinson, Charnley, Burgess, Manfredi, Briscoe, Handley, McGilvary, Oloherts, Uate, Bibby, Jones-Bishop, Johnstone, Faraimo.

With an argument on whether Grace, Marshall and Eden are better.

Re: Salary Cap Value for Money : Mon Jun 03, 2019 9:33 am  

Rogues Gallery wrote:

If Tom Lineham is in the best two wingers in Superleague then it's no wonder the game is in the mess it is.

Correct

Re: Salary Cap Value for Money : Mon Jun 03, 2019 9:28 pm  

Linehams alright. A decent SL winger but no where near the class of Johnstone or Makinson