Re: GAME ON : Hull Kingston Rovers v Castleford Tigers - 19: : Thu Feb 27, 2020 10:59 pm  

craig hkr wrote:

Not unlike Mr Powell?
Tbf I expected a bigger loss.

Tbf I expected a bigger win.

Re: GAME ON : Hull Kingston Rovers v Castleford Tigers - 19: : Thu Feb 27, 2020 11:13 pm  

I can see why the ref gave a sin bin for that. You can easily argue that the Hull KR player has run into the path of the Cas man. If it’s a penalty in that situation it’s pretty much got to be a yellow card as well.

I can also see why the ref gave the Richardson? try and didn’t penalise for obstruction. It looked like the Cas man in front of him was genuinely going for the ball but it went behind him. Though personally if I’d been reffing I’d probably have sent it to the VR. Think that decision is reasonable if it was a non-televised game but was surprised he didn’t use the video ref.

Thought it was good reffing not to sin bin Dagger too. Yes it was a shoulder charge but it was a controlled one and was nowhere near the head.

So 1 good decision and 2x close ones that in real time I agreed with.

Re: GAME ON : Hull Kingston Rovers v Castleford Tigers - 19: : Thu Feb 27, 2020 11:17 pm  

nottinghamtiger wrote:

Tbf I expected a bigger win.

Yep.Different aims for our season's. Looking like another year of strife for us despite Smith getting a tune out of some less celubrious players
Effort and spirit in abundance just need key players back plus at least 1 high quality prop. Will get worse before it gets better.

Re: GAME ON : Hull Kingston Rovers v Castleford Tigers - 19: : Thu Feb 27, 2020 11:19 pm  

Him wrote:

I can see why the ref gave a sin bin for that. You can easily argue that the Hull KR player has run into the path of the Cas man. If it’s a penalty in that situation it’s pretty much got to be a yellow card as well.

I can also see why the ref gave the Richardson? try and didn’t penalise for obstruction. It looked like the Cas man in front of him was genuinely going for the ball but it went behind him. Though personally if I’d been reffing I’d probably have sent it to the VR. Think that decision is reasonable if it was a non-televised game but was surprised he didn’t use the video ref.

Thought it was good reffing not to sin bin Dagger too. Yes it was a shoulder charge but it was a controlled one and was nowhere near the head.

So 1 good decision and 2x close ones that in real time I agreed with.

Fair.
The best team won no doubt but that yellow was pivotal.

Re: GAME ON : Hull Kingston Rovers v Castleford Tigers - 19: : Fri Feb 28, 2020 12:42 am  

I was working and missed the game tonight. Did cas have any injuries?

Re: GAME ON : Hull Kingston Rovers v Castleford Tigers - 19: : Fri Feb 28, 2020 6:18 am  

craig hkr wrote:

No mention of Millington blatant dive? Not at least checking the obstruction try afterwards? Thought Rovers played with plenty of effort and was surprised we ahead at HT. Game as good as gone after that yellow and losing Hadley and Garbutt. Cas didn't need any help tonight but got plenty

No chance. Your player made no effort to collect the ball. He shoulder barged straight into Millington who was going after the ball. 100% a penalty. If he was going for the ball fair enough. Watch it back. His eyes were on Millo and not the ball.

Also no mention of your try which came from a blatant obstruction on the Cas player trying to collect the high ball in your 10 yard line. Again.... Watch it back if you don't agree.

Re: GAME ON : Hull Kingston Rovers v Castleford Tigers - 19: : Fri Feb 28, 2020 7:01 am  

Moe syslak wrote:

I was working and missed the game tonight. Did cas have any injuries?

Fekki, eden, moors, jessie,.foster and cook still out/ not quite ready but very close. Watts has done his tendons in his finger though so that's a month out.

Re: GAME ON : Hull Kingston Rovers v Castleford Tigers - 19: : Fri Feb 28, 2020 7:17 am  

Towns88 wrote:

Fekki, eden, moors, jessie,.foster and cook still out/ not quite ready but very close. Watts has done his tendons in his finger though so that's a month out.

Can't he strap to the next good finger big loss is that

Re: GAME ON : Hull Kingston Rovers v Castleford Tigers - 19: : Fri Feb 28, 2020 7:26 am  

snowie wrote:

Can't he strap to the next good finger big loss is that

Might be more than 1. He did same thing last year. Not ideal at all.

Re: GAME ON : Hull Kingston Rovers v Castleford Tigers - 19: : Fri Feb 28, 2020 7:54 am  

If you can get past the ref bashing, I thought Clares try was up there with the Makinson's and Johnstone tries, unfortunately for him not as often.