That Punch : Sun Oct 12, 2014 7:28 pm  

As regular readers will know I am the only person in the world without sky,
So, youtube only shows the first punch and then the second.
Did Hohaie do something before the tackle?
Even if he did how long a ban should Flower get?
Was it worse than Danes transgretion which got him 10 games.
Was it the coaches instruction?
After all how many forwards did Wigan have on the bench?
Sacrifice a prop to "do" the playmaker?
Didn't work however.
Should legal proceedings be taking against Flower?
Very emotive. I know, but, I do believe hard men don't punch anyone like that on the ground.
My thoughts? I know you will all say "what happens on the field, stays on the field" but for me, legal proceedings followed by at least a one year ban.
Millions watching Rugby League that day, we were very badly let down.

Re: That Punch : Sun Oct 12, 2014 7:43 pm  

What happened was that flower pushed hohia over from a Wigan kick and hohia took offense and forearmed flower in the head. Flower then hit him with the best right hand you've ever seen ( which to me is alright) but he then saw that hohia was clearly knocked out and smacked him bang on the cheek towards the eye which is the most sicken part of it all. and if you look on YouTube I think you can see shaun wane saying knock them out in a half time I think against Huddersfield. and regards to a ban I think 4 months at least. it was much worse than manning's IMO

Re: That Punch : Sun Oct 12, 2014 7:47 pm  

Dutchy the fax fan wrote:

What happened was that flower pushed hohia over from a Wigan kick and hohia took offense and forearmed flower in the head. Flower then hit him with the best right hand you've ever seen ( which to me is alright) but he then saw that hohia was clearly knocked out and smacked him bang on the cheek towards the eye which is the most sicken part of it all. and if you look on YouTube I think you can see shaun wane saying knock them out in a half time I think against Huddersfield. and regards to a ban I think 4 months at least. it was much worse than manning's IMO

The ' push ' was more of a forearm across the back of the head ,Hohaia's was more of a push

No excuses for Flowers

Re: That Punch : Sun Oct 12, 2014 8:02 pm  

I only saw what I thought was a push,but to me it looked like hohaia's reaction he had almost gone in with a forearm 'shove' into flower. but as you say you cant condone flower's actions. His second punch certainly and he should have the book thrown at him

Re: That Punch : Sun Oct 12, 2014 8:03 pm  

Hohaia forearmed him to the jaw and the first punch was fully deserved IMHO but the second was completely unacceptable.
I'd say it was worse than Mannings but I'd be shocked if they gave him the same ban.

Re: That Punch : Sun Oct 12, 2014 8:08 pm  

Norman Bates wrote:

Hohaia forearmed him to the jaw and the first punch was fully deserved IMHO but the second was completely unacceptable.
I'd say it was worse than Mannings but I'd be shocked if they gave him the same ban.

Your opinion of Flowers forearm across the back of Hohaia's head that started it?

Re: That Punch : Sun Oct 12, 2014 8:17 pm  

Must hold my hand up and say I have n't fully seen that. The first lot of cross blows are something that happens most weeks, the floor shot is something we don't want to see ever again.

Re: That Punch : Sun Oct 12, 2014 11:13 pm  

Norman Bates wrote:

Must hold my hand up and say I have n't fully seen that. The first lot of cross blows are something that happens most weeks, the floor shot is something we don't want to see ever again.

Bottom line is Flowers started it, it was all his fault, no excuses

Re: That Punch : Mon Oct 13, 2014 5:04 am  

'have to agree will all above . I have only seen part of the incident that has been shown in a national newspaper 'online'. You don't see a punch like the second one in U F C, it's no wonder he didn't come back on the field, bet he still does not know which planet he is on.
Is sine die too harsh for blatent thuggery?

Re: That Punch : Mon Oct 13, 2014 9:22 am  

I would give Hohia a 2 game ban reduced to 1 given he sat out the grand final. You cant elbow a player in the jaw and I thought flowers first punch was fair dues, the second one indefensible though.

I would give Flower anything between a 10-15 game ban although knowing the rugby league they will give him a time span ban of something like 4 months so it looks like they have banned him for a long time when the reality is that it is a nothing of a ban.

It was ten times worse than what Dane did, nothing in the first tackle Dane did and then had a stand up fight, yes out of order but he didnt punch a barley conscious, unable to defend himself, opponent in the head with a punch that realistically could have killed someone.