Match Officials : Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:01 pm  

Can someone remind me there use?
These are my views
1.the video ref tonight was either stupid or blind
Webb was played onside by Burrow and did not start a forward run until Burrow had passed him
McGuires try was a try the ball went backwards
Sheriffes try was obstructed, there was a possibility of Buchanon tackling the kicker
2. the ref was just poor
Ablett was sent off even though the 'ref' had not called held, is Ablett meant to know if there is no call
one on one rip by sinfield, newtons arm didn't touch the ground so you can still rip it
3. touch judges i am not even going to waste time on them, waste of space just for a change

: Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:05 pm  

How the hell that French ref got a SL license is beyond me. His video decisions tonight was diabolical to say the least!! Last week in the CC he award a Wakey try when he grounded with his stomach rather than his hands.

: Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:05 pm  

ablett was a penalty but the sin bin was harsh.apart from the try every big call went the bulls way. the mcguire try smith was clearly heard telling the useless frog it was a knock on.
the refs are shite, have been since cummings took over, but we were as bad

The most disgusting referee exhibition ever : Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:06 pm  

I have refereed for over 20 years and I apologise for tonight.

An offside player is put onside when a player from an onside player runs in front of you and puts you on onside !!!

Burrows carries the ball in front of Webb and passes to him !! Onside

what happens when a team makes a break and is tackled are all the players running back from an offside position onside once an onside player intervenes !!! That is the view of the ref - you cannot have two rules ??????

The video ref cannot give a forward pass !!!! Period

How can an inside pass be a knock on, the vide ref cannot call on a knock on !!

These decisions are contrary to the rules of the game !!!

I would love an explanation from the HQ

UNDEFENDABLE !!!

Re: Match Officials : Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:07 pm  

Dicko_09 wrote:

Can someone remind me there use?
These are my views
1.the video ref tonight was either stupid or blind
Webb was played onside by Burrow and did not start a forward run until Burrow had passed him
McGuires try was a try the ball went backwards
Sheriffes try was obstructed, there was a possibility of Buchanon tackling the kicker
2. the ref was just poor
Ablett was sent off even though the 'ref' had not called held, is Ablett meant to know if there is no call
one on one rip by sinfield, newtons arm didn't touch the ground so you can still rip it
3. touch judges i am not even going to waste time on them, waste of space just for a change

It was scandelous mate... i can understand one big call going against you in a game but there were 4 huge ones that went against us... i can't imagine how mclennan is feeling and what he's said after the game. Never seen reffereing like it....

: Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:07 pm  

Give it a rest we were beaten, we played poor the points are gone!

: Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:07 pm  

cummings will say he had a great game. he always does. the refs are garbage. but so are we

: Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:07 pm  

tad rhino wrote:

ablett was a penalty but the sin bin was harsh.apart from the try every big call went the bulls way. the mcguire try smith was clearly heard telling the useless frog it was a knock on.
the refs are shite, have been since cummings took over, but we were as bad

yea we was no where near our best but the refs are getting worse, ganson has been reffing better lately which is shocking

: Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:07 pm  

Poor showing by Halibut tonight as video ref. He struggled with the basic rules when he reffed us earlier this season so there is no chance of him understanding anything complex.

Re: The most disgusting referee exhibition ever : Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:09 pm  

rooster_rhino wrote:

I have refereed for over 20 years and I apologise for tonight.

An offside player is put onside when a player from an onside player runs in front of you and puts you on onside !!!

Burrows carries the ball in front of Webb and passes to him !! Onside

what happens when a team makes a break and is tackled are all the players running back from an offside position onside once an onside player intervenes !!! That is the view of the ref - you cannot have two rules ??????

The video ref cannot give a forward pass !!!! Period

How can an inside pass be a knock on, the vide ref cannot call on a knock on !!

These decisions are contrary to the rules of the game !!!

I would love an explanation from the HQ

UNDEFENDABLE !!!

bang on m8 these refs are idiots who need to learn the rules