Re: Sam Burgess Union debut : Mon Aug 17, 2015 12:30 pm  

Leaguefan wrote:

RL has never really known how to promote or market the game. Brilliant product though.
RU has always known how to promote and market the game. Poor product though.
Soccer really doesn't have to promote its game because it is so simple yet people try to explain it's complicated when it isn't.
The real question is why isn't an excellent product so well known and despite efforts so far, it isn't?
There are obvious answers, but I would suggest that by looking at everything from different angles, coming up with a viable proposition and working with it, it could be done. It will cost, no doubt, but then the clubs would rather throw money away on 2nd rate players etc rather than take an income cut and combine to get a good marketing & development plan going.
However, if people are happy with the current situation then so be it. The games potion is locked and progress, if any, will be at a pace to suit. Just watch others leave RL behind.

I would tend to agree; I think the clubs and the RFL have a shared responsibility to raise the profile of the game and as you say - that takes investment. We seemed to be on the right track a bit with the Extraordinary Rugby themed stuff a couple of years ago - finally focussing on the players and personalities within the game, which is what will sell it; but like most RFL initiatives, that appears to have fizzled out.

I'd suggest that a top-down restructure of the RFL would be the starting point - the sport should be lead by someone with the vision and talent to promote the game effectively and I wouldn't be against a top-slice of central funding to create a proper PR team to help them achieve that; if that helped clubs shift more ST's and/or sponsorship deals, the return on that lost income should be enough to appease even the whiniest of club chairmen.

It's all pie in the sky of course - we seem as a sport to be satisfied with our place as a colloquial northern pastime and I can see no real desire to make the drastic kind of changes that are needed to shift this particular paradigm; unless the billion dollar TV deal in Australia prompts some of the more forward thinking chairmen start asking some uncomfortable questions of Big Nige and co?

Re: Sam Burgess Union debut : Mon Aug 17, 2015 12:54 pm  

I was at the game on Saturday.....1st time at Twickenham. I was there as a guest of the RFU with the junior team that I coach. The stadium was excellent...great facilities, well organised...not quite as good as Wembley...but not far off. The game was terrible...total bore-fest. The 1st half was OK....I literally can't remember anything about the 2nd half....a truly awful sporting spectacle. And the atmosphere in the stadium was non-existent. I've been in better atmospheres at Wilderspool with 4,500 people watching.

As for Burgess...he will have seen more proper action in a full contact training session at Souths.

I have got a good chance of getting hold of England v Australia World Cup tickets....and if I do...I will sell them on and make a tidy sum.

Rugby Union.....its the emperors new clothes.

Re: Sam Burgess Union debut : Mon Aug 17, 2015 1:20 pm  

Oxford Exile wrote:

Rugby Union.....its the emperors new clothes.

And always has been.

For me, it was a case of 'once seen, never again'.

And when they place it side-by-side with League, like Leeds did on Friday, it really does highlight how good one code is and how bad the other is.

It's one of the biggest media conspiracies, given how long they've grossly over-hyped that garbage.

Re: Sam Burgess Union debut : Mon Aug 17, 2015 1:38 pm  

Oxford Exile wrote:

I was at the game on Saturday.....1st time at Twickenham. I was there as a guest of the RFU with the junior team that I coach. The stadium was excellent...great facilities, well organised...not quite as good as Wembley...but not far off. The game was terrible...total bore-fest. The 1st half was OK....I literally can't remember anything about the 2nd half....a truly awful sporting spectacle. And the atmosphere in the stadium was non-existent. I've been in better atmospheres at Wilderspool with 4,500 people watching.

As for Burgess...he will have seen more proper action in a full contact training session at Souths.

I have got a good chance of getting hold of England v Australia World Cup tickets....and if I do...I will sell them on and make a tidy sum.

Rugby Union.....its the emperors new clothes.

So if one bad half and a bad atmosphere in one game makes the whole of the sport rubbish that means RL is poopie as I've seen some awful games with church-like atmospheres in Super League. Or, conveniently, does that not apply to RL?

Re: Sam Burgess Union debut : Mon Aug 17, 2015 1:52 pm  

I'm leaning towards Galliant on this one.

Oxford Exile goes to one game, which has the same meaning as a SL pre-season friendly, and tells everyone the atmos & game was crap. No poop.

Re: Sam Burgess Union debut : Mon Aug 17, 2015 2:13 pm  

I read it that he was using his experience at that game to illustrate a broader view that the product is poor; as opposed to suggesting that's his first and only experience of RU and he was making a judgement about the whole sport off the back of it. Given that he also said he coaches a jr RU team, I think my interpretation is probably closer to the truth.

But I'm sure he can speak for himself.

Re: Sam Burgess Union debut : Mon Aug 17, 2015 2:42 pm  

I played yawnion for 5 years at school & watched it for 20. It's poop.

Re: Sam Burgess Union debut : Mon Aug 17, 2015 4:51 pm  

This whole 69 page thread has reminded me of something a famous Welsh rugby player who played RL for a while (for the money) once said at my local RFC- 'I think Union and League fans have alot in common. They are both obsessed with Union.'

Re: Sam Burgess Union debut : Mon Aug 17, 2015 5:04 pm  

galliant wrote:

This whole 69 page thread has reminded me of something a famous Welsh rugby player who played RL for a while (for the money) once said at my local RFC- 'I think Union and League fans have alot in common. They are both obsessed with Union.'

That's amusing coming from a union fan who spends a worrying amount of time stalking a rugby league forum.

Re: Sam Burgess Union debut : Mon Aug 17, 2015 5:15 pm  

I'm a fan of both codes so can comment on both. If by 'stalking' you mean 'looking at' then that makes you a stalker too.