Inspired but odd : Mon May 01, 2017 8:25 am  

I can not have been alone when hearing the team read out to be somewhat baffled by the selection of three forwards and a three quarter on he bench.

Turned out to be inspired considering TJ's early loss. However it does defy conventional wisdom.

Any theories, I have one but i'll wait and see what others think before saying owt

Re: Inspired but odd : Mon May 01, 2017 8:38 am  

It was explained by Chester afterwards...with Kirmond dropping out the plan was to ease Lyne back in with a 20-30 minute stint in the centre and put Arundel in the back row when he came on...circumstances meant he came on and had to play 75 minutes...and I must say...after quite a while out I thought he was excellent...we've got some great options in the three quarters at the moment...club have done superbly in putting together a squad with very good strength in depth in just about all areas, while still spending less than everyone else!

Re: Inspired but odd : Mon May 01, 2017 8:44 am  

CC wanted to get Reece Lyne some game time to test his fitness without sending him on dual reg. Planned to give him 15-20 minster at the end. The usual bench is 2 props a 2nd row and interchange hooked. As we only have 1 hooker, Hadley swapped to give Wood a rest, thus giving the space on the bench.

[PopTart]

Re: Inspired but odd : Mon May 01, 2017 9:16 am  

When all the centres are fit I'm not sure who I'd play.
Arundel was excellent yesterday and for me was the one who changed the game our way.

But then Lyne looked good and Tupou was at his best before injury.

Then add to that I've been pleasantly surprised with MCB in the centre and Gibson showed some great attacking skills.

Good problem to have.

Re: Inspired but odd : Mon May 01, 2017 10:14 am  

PopTart wrote:

When all the centres are fit I'm not sure who I'd play.
Arundel was excellent yesterday and for me was the one who changed the game our way.

But then Lyne looked good and Tupou was at his best before injury.

Then add to that I've been pleasantly surprised with MCB in the centre and Gibson showed some great attacking skills.

Good problem to have.

Agree with that assessment except Gibson. He's markedly not as strong as the other centres.

[PopTart]

Re: Inspired but odd : Mon May 01, 2017 10:48 am  

Adam_Harrison9 wrote:

Agree with that assessment except Gibson. He's markedly not as strong as the other centres.

Yes. I do think he has defensive frailties but not sure whether that is confidence after injury.
I like his attack though but he's last on the list right now.

Re: Inspired but odd : Mon May 01, 2017 10:58 am  

PopTart wrote:

Yes. I do think he has defensive frailties but not sure whether that is confidence after injury.
I like his attack though but he's last on the list right now.

I would certainly agree that its confidence as I thought Gibson got better with every game he played until his injury and if he gets the game time would expect him to keep improving but because of the way the others are playing its a big task to claim a regular spot
Like you said a nice position to be in

Re: Inspired but odd : Mon May 01, 2017 11:39 am  

I was impressed by Lynne's pace yesterday, he tracked BJB all the way to the try line. Think he was showing off a bit personally.

Re: Inspired but odd : Mon May 01, 2017 12:16 pm  

vastman wrote:

I can not have been alone when hearing the team read out to be somewhat baffled by the selection of three forwards and a three quarter on he bench.

Turned out to be inspired considering TJ's early loss. However it does defy conventional wisdom.

Any theories, I have one but i'll wait and see what others think before saying owt

I don't think we had any other choice vasty, we'd run out of hookers and half backs but like you say, it payed off.

Re: Inspired but odd : Mon May 01, 2017 12:34 pm  

That was a testing comeback for Lynne but he came through with flying colours.

Bit concerned about ineffective and injury prone Anthony England has become. Along side Huby, Fifita and even Hirst he really looks off the pace.