And he's back : Fri Jun 29, 2018 9:00 pm  

Having thought James Child had maybe turned a corner.....we see he hasn't. That double movement decision not to go to the screen is just appalling. Barba decision just as bad. Disgraceful. Once an incompetent **** always an incompetent ****

Re: And he's back : Fri Jun 29, 2018 9:32 pm  

He’s a cheat it’s that simple. Planted by the rfl.

Re: And he's back : Fri Jun 29, 2018 9:47 pm  

What an absolute effing sickener

Re: And he's back : Fri Jun 29, 2018 9:50 pm  

Wexford Trinity wrote:

He’s a cheat it’s that simple. Planted by the rfl.

At least the +16 coupon handicap wasn't breached!

Re: And he's back : Fri Jun 29, 2018 10:37 pm  

Wexford Trinity wrote:

He’s a cheat it’s that simple. Planted by the rfl.

Incompetent at times maybe, a cheat give yer nogging a shake

Re: And he's back : Fri Jun 29, 2018 11:02 pm  

I've only just got over the last time Saints won at belle vue over a disputed try in front of the cameras for all to see,
tonight is far worse than that, inept is being kind,
while I'm not daft to think the Saints don't deserve to be where they are, we should of come away with a better result tonight than that.
to be truthful I'm sick of propping the rest up **** all to play for, sicking decisions like this is making think why I bother following the sport any more.

Re: And he's back : Sat Jun 30, 2018 9:04 am  

chissitt wrote:

Incompetent at times maybe, a cheat give yer nogging a shake

I think he’s something between incompetent and a cheat. Where he’s cheating is by over rating himself through vanity I assume.

Not going to the VR especially for a ref renouned for its use is more than incompetent to me. It’s willfull disregard for the rights of the fans for an honest game.

Had it been any other ref I reckon they would have sent it up ditto if we were Leeds or Wigan - can you imagine SOL reaction if he’d have been playing.

There was simply no excuse not to go to the VR imo.

It’s a hard gig reffing and I couldn’t do it but at this level where ultimately jobs and businesses are at stake you have to be the best and far to often Child’s falls short - it’s harsh because I’m sure he’s a great guy but you put yourself up there you have to deliver. He needs to go for me.

Re: And he's back : Sat Jun 30, 2018 9:06 am  

snowie wrote:

I've only just got over the last time Saints won at belle vue over a disputed try in front of the cameras for all to see,
tonight is far worse than that, inept is being kind,
while I'm not daft to think the Saints don't deserve to be where they are, we should of come away with a better result tonight than that.
to be truthful I'm sick of propping the rest up **** all to play for, sicking decisions like this is making think why I bother following the sport any more.

My sentiments exactly the same snowie.

[PopTart]

Re: And he's back : Sat Jun 30, 2018 9:14 am  

I don't like players and coaches having a go at the ref all the time. There needs to be respect of their role on the pitch.
Equally I'm not the type to blame the ref for a loss as there are always way more mistakes by players that cost the game.

However, I would like to see an official response when it is obvious on tv that a mistake has been made. The Batchelor incident could possibly be explained if the ref could clarify what they saw and how they interpreted it. The double movement was a clear error. TV proves it and it isn't an interpretation, he just didn't get it right for some reason, and didn't go to the ref.
I don't think it has to be a discussion, I just think it should be explained.

Re: And he's back : Sat Jun 30, 2018 9:19 am  

vastman wrote:

I think he’s something between incompetent and a cheat. Where he’s cheating is by over rating himself through vanity I assume.

Not going to the VR especially for a ref renouned for its use is more than incompetent to me. It’s willfull disregard for the rights of the fans for an honest game.

There was simply no excuse not to go to the VR imo.

It’s a hard gig reffing and I couldn’t do it but at this level where ultimately jobs and businesses are at stake you have to be the best and far to often Child’s falls short - it’s harsh because I’m sure he’s a great guy but you put yourself up there you have to deliver. He needs to go for me.

Spot on once again I could not agree more, although I'm not sure that he needs to go maybe that's a bit drastic, but my point and I still stick by it is that I don't think he's a cheat, and I base that to some extent that I haven't read a post from a fan of any club who has anything good to say about him, perhaps a consistent incompetent describes him best