Just a thought. : Wed Apr 20, 2022 7:19 pm  

I am a WP fan & I am still sure he is Good for us & @ the right cost for us @ the club. I am also aware he only has till the end of the season on his contract.
However, if we are ever to better the club, players & therefore the culture of this madness we have I would love to keep WP, but as an assistant to Tony Smith who would probably only stay 1 or 2 seasons & then WP, to continue the good work, TS, leaves club's in a better position playing wise & WP, is after all mentored by Tony Smith.
This will not happen but OMG, I wish !

[PopTart]

Re: Just a thought. : Wed Apr 20, 2022 9:41 pm  

No.
Willie is in charge. Leave him to do his job.

Re: Just a thought. : Thu Apr 21, 2022 5:49 am  

PopTart wrote:

No.
Willie is in charge. Leave him to do his job.

that's what I like to see dismiss an opportunity to improve the club with one of the best super league coaches that's been here and for what? don't tell me you like Willy and wouldn't want to upset him.
for gawd sake its a team event and if that meant improving the club by him joining the team then it should happen, probably the best suggestion in yonks and like TT said they have worked together and I'm sure he wouldn't feel like his nose has been shoved out

Re: Just a thought. : Thu Apr 21, 2022 6:12 am  

Willie is far down the pecking order of people that need to step aside at the club IMO ,would a top NRL coach make any perceivable improvement/difference v cost of salary ,I think not . First off players need to have a long hard look at themselves and ask themselves if they are here to make the numbers up , take a wage or play for the honour of the badge ,I’d suggest we have some that if the truth be known are here for no other reason than the aforementioned. How we can possibly judge willies short tenure coaching someone else’s team is quite frankly a knee jerk reaction ,we put up with Chester for the last two seasons and his abysmal record ,let give Willie some slack . I have every faith in poaching ,he’s been around and learned from the best in super league for his apprenticeship ,he was a winner in his playing days , I’m sure he’ll be hurting as much if not more than us ,and if money was available I’m positive there would be incomings . But we cut our cloth accordingly and move on .

Re: Just a thought. : Thu Apr 21, 2022 7:42 am  

Going to Leeds

Re: Just a thought. : Thu Apr 21, 2022 8:00 am  

alegend wrote:

Going to Leeds

What you are, going shopping?

Tony Smith has said that he isn't going to Leeds (nearest will be Pontefract squash club ), but his nephew Rohan is.

Re: Just a thought. : Thu Apr 21, 2022 8:15 am  

TrinTrin wrote:

I am a WP fan & I am still sure he is Good for us & @ the right cost for us @ the club. I am also aware he only has till the end of the season on his contract.
However, if we are ever to better the club, players & therefore the culture of this madness we have I would love to keep WP, but as an assistant to Tony Smith who would probably only stay 1 or 2 seasons & then WP, to continue the good work, TS, leaves club's in a better position playing wise & WP, is after all mentored by Tony Smith.
This will not happen but OMG, I wish !

In case you'd forgotten Poching was mentored by Smith so perhaps he's learned all he can from him, Smith is leaving at the end of the season because his contract is up and being the gent he is, is fulfilling his obligations, wishful thinking on your part or not it would be good in an ideal world, unfortunately we don't do ideal really, one other thing I don't suppose you'd personally like to run this past Willie would you

Re: Just a thought. : Thu Apr 21, 2022 9:24 am  

What Smith does wherever he goes is create a great culture that seems to remain after he leaves, I think he would be a brilliant DOR for a few years for us, the relationship he already has with WP would be a bonus, as much as MC and JM run the club well, he`s not a rugby man and an extra head with the coach to look at all things rugby i.e. recruitment with the experience and knowledge of TS imho is what we have been crying out for. Kear for me played a similar role for us and it told on field both when he was present with us and for a couple years after, the problem with that is his tenure was cut short before the job was done.

I know we had issue with Brian Smith, similar to the flaws Tony references at Hull KR re not having control of the organisation in the departments he needed to to have the influence he needed, if TS is available and willing I would throw the kitchen sink at him to take a role here, everywhere he has been he has turned the club around and that speaks volume.

[PopTart]

Re: Just a thought. : Thu Apr 21, 2022 9:27 am  

snowie wrote:

that's what I like to see dismiss an opportunity to improve the club with one of the best super league coaches that's been here and for what? don't tell me you like Willy and wouldn't want to upset him.
for gawd sake its a team event and if that meant improving the club by him joining the team then it should happen, probably the best suggestion in yonks and like TT said they have worked together and I'm sure he wouldn't feel like his nose has been shoved out

I wouldn't turn down some consultancy.
But to appoint a leader and then undermine him by appointing someone above him is more damaging than the benefits of brining Smith in as top dog.

Re: Just a thought. : Thu Apr 21, 2022 9:53 am  

There is also the small matter of wages as I doubt he'd be coming for nowt, whom or what gets sacrificed to make this happen?.