Re: Major talking points : Fri Jul 29, 2011 9:30 pm  

Black and white legend wrote:

Tomkins first try IMO was a double movement
Obst disallowed try Wigan player fell off the tackle
Richards second try markers not standing square at play the ball- should have been Hull penalty

General performance od Thaler/Ganson awful

tomkins try was fine, ball carrying arm never hit the deck

Obst try the emphasis is on the attacking player to withdraw from the line, thus Lauaki was obstructing.

Re: Major talking points : Fri Jul 29, 2011 9:30 pm  

Black and white legend wrote:

Tomkins first try IMO was a double movement
Obst disallowed try Wigan player fell off the tackle
Richards second try markers not standing square at play the ball- should have been Hull penalty

General performance od Thaler/Ganson awful

I kind of agree that the refereeing wasn't brilliant, but is it any coincidence that this keeps happening? We need to smarten up, we always get close to the big teams, but hardly ever get over the line. We have massive brain explosions at the wrong times.

Re: Major talking points : Fri Jul 29, 2011 9:31 pm  

Black and white legend wrote:

How was it fine Paul the ball carrying arm hit the ground therefore tackle complete Tomkins then span and put the ball down eqals double movement

Because his momentum wasnt stopped.

Re: Major talking points : Fri Jul 29, 2011 9:32 pm  

Old_Faithful_IAKW wrote:

It was Turner's fault not Whiting's.

was it turner? if so my mistake, still cost us 6 points regardless

Re: Major talking points : Fri Jul 29, 2011 9:33 pm  

Leggysfaithful wrote:

I kind of agree that the refereeing wasn't brilliant, but is it any coincidence that this keeps happening? We need to smarten up, we always get close to the big teams, but hardly ever get over the line. We have massive brain explosions at the wrong times.

The amount of possession we had early on and the fact we did not convert it to points is criminal. We did the same against Leeds.

Re: Major talking points : Fri Jul 29, 2011 9:33 pm  

IMO the tomkins try was good, Obsts try also!! cant comment on the decisions made tonight, ill watch it on sky+ then i wont embarrass myself!!

Re: Major talking points : Fri Jul 29, 2011 9:33 pm  

number 6 wrote:

was it turner? if so my mistake, still cost us 6 points regardless

It was Turner.

[Chris71]

Re: Major talking points : Fri Jul 29, 2011 9:34 pm  

hullbg wrote:

The amount of possession we had early on and the fact we did not convert it to points is criminal. We did the same against Leeds.

Pretty much sums up the season and season before that and season before that and no doubt if Agar is the Coach again next season it will be same, nothing ever changes or improves under him.

Re: Major talking points : Fri Jul 29, 2011 9:36 pm  

Chris71 wrote:

Pretty much sums up the season and season before that and season before that and no doubt if Agar is the Coach again next season it will be same, nothing ever changes or improves under him.

We struggle because we dont have a true halfback pairing. A lot will say well its not Agars fault Long is injured, but anyone who puts faith in a crock playing a full season is deluded. We should have brought in a backup for the inevitable Long injuries.

Re: Major talking points : Fri Jul 29, 2011 9:37 pm  

hullbg wrote:

We struggle because we dont have a true halfback pairing. A lot will say well its not Agars fault Long is injured, but anyone who puts faith in a crock playing a full season is deluded. We should have brought in a backup for the inevitable Long injuries.

We did . Obst